The KENYA INSTITUTE for PUBLIC POLICY RESEARCH and ANALYSIS No. 8/2023-2024 Thinking Policy Together Advancing Kenya’s Digital Literacy Initiatives in Arid and Semi-Arid Lands By Austin Odera and Alex Matiy Key Highlights Digital literacy is an essential aspect in the development of any country. Digital literacy ensures that all individuals and communities who may be marginalized or underserved have access to and can effectively use digital technologies and the Internet. This policy brief focuses on interventions towards advancing the role of digital inclusion through literacy in unlocking the potential of Kenya’s arid and semi-arid lands (ASALs). Key highlights include: i) As of 2022, Kenya’s Digital Literacy Programme was making significant strides in preparing students for the digital age, aiming to modernize the education system for the 21st century. Nearly 98.67 per cent of schools had implemented the programme nationwide. However, there are disparities among regions and the digital literacy level is below 50 per cent for ASAL counties. In Kenya’s ASALs, Samburu has the lowest digital literacy rate. At the same time, Kiambu stands out with the highest digital literacy rate. ii) Digital divide in Kenya exists, and it deepens existing social inequalities, limiting access to education, employment, healthcare, and civic participation. iii) Current digital literacy efforts in Kenya are not cohesive, especially in reaching marginalized communities. The initiatives are not standardized, face insufficient funding, and have limited comprehensive approach. Existing policies prioritize basic skills, neglecting critical aspects such as critical thinking and cybersecurity. Coverage is limited countrywide, and access costs are high. iv) A proposed National Digital Literacy Framework can establish clear learning objectives and standards adaptable to various learning environments, benefiting from input from educators and technology experts. Targeted programmes for marginalized communities may have the potential to provide access to technology and training, with collaboration among local leaders and non-profit organizations to enhance programme effectiveness. Additionally, teacher training, offering continuous development, is crucial for effective digital literacy integration and should consider diverse teaching styles and student needs. Introduction Digital Literacy in Kenya In the 21st century, digital literacy has become Digital divide is a multifaceted issue associated with a fundamental skill for individual empowerment, disparities in access to technology, education, and economic progress, and societal development. resources. While the Internet has the potential to be Technology’s rapid advancement has transformed a great equalizer, many people lack the basic digital how we communicate, work, and access information. skills. This divide deepens existing social inequalities, However, a digital divide persists, leaving a significant limiting access to education, employment, healthcare, portion of the population without the necessary skills to and civic participation. The aftermath of COVID-19 navigate the digital landscape. This policy brief explores pandemic reinforced the importance of digital literacy, the critical need for comprehensive digital literacy as remote learning and telemedicine have become programmes to bridge this gap and ensure equitable essential, leaving those without digital skills severely access to opportunities in the digital age. disadvantaged. The sustainable development goal KIPPRA Policy Brief No. 8/2023-2024 1 (SDG) target for Internet and broadband aims that by Digital Literacy levels 2025, 60 per cent of youth and adults should have With a lowest digital literacy score of 27.56%, Samburu achieved at least a minimum level of proficiency faces challenges in digital literacy, especially regarding in sustainable digital skills. Digital skills have been computer/tablet usage, Internet access, and the defined as skills that enable people to access, use, and presence of a Digital Learning Programme (DLP). benefit from the Internet, enhance Internet penetration, and access to employment and entrepreneur The moderate digital literacy cluster encompasses opportunities. It is estimated that by 2030, digital skills seven counties, each scoring between 30 and 40 per will be required in most of the jobs in Kenya. Limited cent in digital literacy. Garissa, Wajir, Mandera, Turkana, knowledge and skills in ICT in the ASALs of Kenya West Pokot, and Isiolo form this cluster. While these are a significant barrier to households’ Internet use, counties exhibit moderate digital literacy levels, there which prevents them from exploiting its benefits even is room for improvement in computer/tablet usage, during emergencies or disasters. Digital skills are Internet access, and presence of Digital Literacy measured from basic to intermediate to advanced Programme. levels. Basic skills, including hardware, software, and basic online tasks, form the foundation for functioning The high digital literacy cluster comprises 21 counties, in society. Intermediate skills go further, allowing critical all boasting digital literacy scores exceeding 40 per technology use and content creation, particularly for cent. Marsabit, Kwale, Kilifi, Taita Taveta, Kajiado, work-related tasks such as digital marketing. Advanced Makueni, Kitui, Machakos, Embu, Tharaka Nithi, skills are specialized, including programming, Artificial Meru, Laikipia, Baringo, Narok, Nakuru, Migori, Nyeri, Intelligence(AI), big data, and cybersecurity, often Kiambu, and Elgeyo Marakwet belong to this cluster. requiring advanced education and leading to higher- These counties exhibit strong digital literacy levels, with paying roles, particularly in ICT professions. Table 1: Share of Internet usage, tablet/computer use and schools with DLP (%) County %of the Population Age % of Population Age 3 % of Schools with Digital literacy 3 Years and Above Using Years and Above Using a Digital Literacy score(%) Internet Computer/Laptop/Tablet Program Tana River 8.9 3.2 100.00 34.950 Isiolo 14.2 5.3 83.00 31.280 Garissa 12.2 4.6 93.87 33.660 Wajir 8.3 2.9 100.00 33.650 Samburu 9.7 4.1 76.71 27.560 Mandera 7.8 2.7 100.00 33.420 Marsabit 8.3 3.0 100.00 33.690 Turkana 6.9 2.4 98.88 32.694 Kwale 12.4 4.6 99.45 35.385 Kilifi 15.1 6.6 100.00 37.170 Taita Taveta 23.9 9.6 100.00 40.010 Kajiado 33.1 16.2 99.75 46.353 Makueni 16.1 6.1 100.00 37.270 Kitui 13.6 4.9 99.60 35.920 Machakos 25.8 11.8 99.76 42.388 Embu 22.1 9.4 100.00 40.390 Tharaka Nithi 18.8 8.2 99.52 38.784 Meru 19.3 7.1 99.72 38.536 Laikipia 22.6 9.5 98.97 40.271 West Pokot 8.1 3.0 100.00 33.630 Baringo 15.3 6.2 99.69 37.957 Narok 12.0 4.1 99.84 35.212 Nakuru 26.8 11.6 99.71 42.597 Migori 14.3 6.1 99.67 36.634 Homabay 15.2 6.8 100.00 38.120 Nyeri 29.9 13.7 99.49 44.292 Kiambu 42.7 21.8 98.27 51.002 Lamu 19.4 6.2 97.85 39.975 Elgeyo Markakwet 14.2 5.5 100.00 36.460 2 KIPPRA Policy Brief No. 8/2023-2024 scores reflecting proficiency in computer/tablet usage, Policy Recommendations internet access, and Digital Literacy Program presence. The National Digital Literacy Framework can provide Within this high digital literacy cluster, Kiambu stands clear learning objectives and standards, and ensuring out with the highest Digital Literacy score of 51.00 per adaptability to diverse learning environments. This cent, indicating exceptional digital literacy. Nyeri follows could be supported with the following interventions: closely with a Digital Literacy score of 44.29 per cent, while other counties in this cluster display varying i) Targeted programmes for marginalized degrees of digital proficiency. communities: Digital literacy programmes can focus on providing access to technology and Government initiatives training. Collaborating with local leaders and Various government initiatives at the national and non-profit organizations may enhance cultural county levels and efforts from the private sector have sensitivity and programme effectiveness. been put in place to enhance digital skills and literacy in Kenya. The digital literacy programme, for example, ii) Teacher training and curriculum integration: ensures that every student is well-equipped for the Educators can receive continuous training to digital era, aiming to modernize the education system integrate digital literacy effectively. Training into a 21st century model. Ajira Digital Programme is programmes may need to be tailored to suit a national government initiative to empower over one different teaching styles and student needs. million young individuals to access digital employment opportunities. An important aspect of this initiative iii) Public-private partnerships: Partnerships is emphasizing education and skill development can fund digital literacy initiatives, but ethical tailored for the constantly changing landscape of guidelines may be necessary to ensure equitable online jobs. The programme has achieved notable distribution of resources and opportunities. success by granting Kenyans access to various online iv) Awareness campaigns: Awareness campaigns digital job opportunities and fostering partnerships can utilize diverse media channels to reach a and collaborations that have proven beneficial for wider audience. However, understanding the the country. It collaborates with 56 established digital cultural nuances of different regions may be platforms, offering various services, from business crucial for the message’s effectiveness. development to ensuring efficient technology access. v) Monitoring and evaluation: A robust monitoring Current efforts to address digital literacy often lack system can track programme outcomes and cohesion and fail to effectively reach marginalized participant engagement, but it may require communities. While various initiatives are in place, regular reviews and adjustments based on they often have no standardization, adequate funding, evolving digital trends and community needs. and a comprehensive approach. Additionally, there is limited awareness among policy makers regarding the vi) Internet expansion: Expanding Internet coverage urgency and impact of digital literacy on overall societal can enhance accessibility, especially in remote development. Furthermore, existing policies primarily areas. However, environmental factors and focus on basic digital skills, overlooking the importance infrastructure challenges may influence the of advanced digital literacy, including critical thinking, feasibility and effectiveness of such expansions. media literacy, and cyber security. The coverage across the country is also limited in addition to the high cost of access. References Communications Authority of Kenya(2020), The State of the ICT Industry in Kenya Report 2020. ICT Authority (2023), DigiSchool Management System. PILLARS OF THE DIGITAL LITERACY PROGRAM. https://www.digischool.go.ke/ Ministry of ICT, Innovation and Youth Affairs (2021), The Kenya National Digital Master Plan 2022-2032. Ministry of Information, Communications and Technology (2019), Digital Economy Blueprint. MOICT (2022), Over 5,000 Government services now available from 100+ Ministries, Counties, Departments and Agencies. Gava Mkononi. MOICT (2023). Ajira Digital. KIPPRA Policy Brief No. 8/2023-2024 3 Acknowledgements This policy brief was prepared by Austin Odera and Alex Matiy (Young Professionals) based on a discussion paper titled “Pivoting Digital Inclusion to Unlock Kenya’s ASALs: An ICT Composite Index Approach” About KIPPRA Policy Briefs For More Information Contact: KIPPRA Policy Briefs are aimed at a wide dissemination of the Institute’s policy research findings. The findings are Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research and Analysis expected to stimulate discussion and also build capacity Bishops Road, Bishops Garden Towers in the public policy making process in Kenya. P.O. Box 56445-00200, Nairobi Tel: 2719933/4, Cell: 0736712724, 0724256078 KIPPRA acknowledges generous support from the Email:admin@kippra.or.ke Government of Kenya and development partners who Website: http://www.kippra.or.ke have continued to support the Institute’s activities over @KIPPRAKenya the years. 4 KIPPRA Policy Brief No. 8/2023-2024